Steal This: Newsletter for Creatives & Artists Formula

By Jessica Craddock | Email Marketing

May 19
creatives and artists newsletter formula

Drawing a blank on what you should talk about in your emails? Learn the newsletter for creatives formula so you'll easily know what to talk about, connect like a real person with your ideal art buyer, and gently guide them by the hand to what you want them to do next.

  In this epic article:

(click title to scroll)

  Coming soon to this article:
  • Remind them what you're selling and who you are 
tell a story in creative newsletter

This weekend my daughter and I played in the mud. I got out a wide and deep plastic feed bowl, filled it with potting soil and let her get it wet with our OXO watering can until it was a sloppy mess. She spread mud all over her face and flung her dirty hands around until it was all over me and the patio. 

Not only was it fun, but she helped me make 120 cubes of dirt, called seed blocks. We drop seeds right into the blocks where they germinate indoors and get a head start on our short gardening season. This time we started sunflower, green bean, pumpkin, melon, and squash seeds. 

Why am I talking to you about my garden fetish when you just want to know how to write an email to your list?

Because you're a captive audience and no one else will listen to me ramble on about seeds. Bwahahaha... 

Just kidding. I want to illustrate how to insert "you" into your marketing. Maybe you care about plants, and maybe you don't, but now you know something personal about me in addition to this nifty little lesson I'm about to share with you. 

Most people get tripped up when they hear they need to be relatable and talk about their interests in their marketing. They mistakenly decide they need to write a whole email about arranging bouquets, confusing their list who thought they signed up for art updates.

I like to get around that little problem by giving out "twofers," or two for ones. It's an early 20th-century term that used to refer to getting two cigars for one-quarter of a cent. When I say it, I mean "share something about you and find a way to relate it to whatever you were originally writing about." Roll it all together like a spring roll. You can also do it with social media posts! 

If you understand your Ideal Art Buyer, this is a beautiful way to grab their attention with interests or values you share and endear yourself to them. 

Have you ever been subscribed to a list where the emails you receive are all facts and business updates? These can often be flat and boring. Show them you are a three-dimensional person they can relate to. Let them know you're a whole person with thoughts, beliefs, stories, and interests. 

STEP 1: Turn yourself into a real person with an intro story. 

Here are a few prompts to get the ideas rolling for you: 

  • What's on your mind? If you had a friend in front of you right now, what would you be itching to sit down and talk about?
  • What lesson have you learned from your average, everyday life recently?
  • What thought is weighing on you right now?
  • Who do you admire?
  • What did you do this week?
  • What do you believe in?
  • What interests do you have in common with your Ideal Art Buyer?
  • What are the things you care most about in your life that you have in common with your Ideal Art Buyer? 
Tips to make it great
  • You don't have to tell an entire story. The beginning, middle, or end is often enough. Even a sentence or two can get the job done.
  • Use factual adjectives and descriptive verbs to help the reader see what your life looks like. 
homework for an artist's online art business

Create and favorite a document in Google Docs (or Evernote or Asana) where you can keep a running list of story ideas as they pop in your head. Copy and paste in the story prompts above. 

There you have it! Part one of my email writing formula. I'll be back with part two - tying the story to the "meat" of your email - next week. Talk to you Tuesday! 😉

purpose of newsletter for creatives

It was my mother's 60th birthday this week, so I wanted to get her something special. A gift that would remind her that I love her... in her language. She loves the spaces around her to be pristine and contain beautiful things.

My first thought was art, obviously, but I've given her so much her walls are full. My grandmother has been adding flowers to the hillside outside their window, so I decided to contribute a feminine looking rose bush with double purple/pink blooms to their view. They'll come back every year and remind her I care about her.

I looked for a personal connection (her love language is beauty) and added my own message to it (remember I love you). The perfect gift formula, in my opinion!

That's also why I love to create emails the way I do - there's a personal connection included with my message. It's not all about my agenda. It's about growing a relationship with you.

That being said, the message is just as important as the connection.

What was the message of your last email? Was it, "hey... it's time for me to send my monthly newsletter again so here's some random stuff I wrote"?

I want to challenge you to think a little more strategically. Decide on your email's purpose BEFORE you write it. For your sake and your reader's. Don't clutter their inbox with some useless crap just because it's time to send another email.

Give your newsletter a will to live! Let it feel like it has a life purpose!

Do you want to:

  • Tell them about something coming up
  • Ask for a sale
  • Ask for a follow
  • Ask for a share
  • Inspire their day
  • Give them something
  • Tell them about this new cool thing they'd like 
PRO TIP: Notice some of these things are for your benefit, and some are for theirs.

This is a business, so you've got to learn to ask for what you need. But... a good business is a two-way street. With a relationship-based art company, you serve them, and they serve you. 

STEP 2: Tie your story to the email's purpose. 

Once you know the point of your email, you need to tie it to the intro. Practice telling the intro story in different ways until one of those versions leads into the message of your email.

For example, I might want to talk about how I've started waking up at 5am to get things done because my four year old daughter isn't in daycare two days a week anymore. If the point of my email is to ask for a follow, I might talk about how dedication to showing up is one of the significant milestones to becoming a professional artist. And, by the way, if you're serious about becoming a professional artist, you might want to follow me on Pinterest because I share dozens of articles a week that can help you.

Or, perhaps I want to talk about how I'm the luckiest girl alive because I moved onto a property with an orchard. If the point of my email is to inspire your day, I might talk about how it was overgrown and not very productive, but with lots of love, mulching, pruning and several years of work, now I have amazing fruit that I can just walk out my door and grab when I feed my chickens. Which would lead to... If you consistently practice marketing, you'll start to learn what your business needs to thrive. Practice those things regularly to increase your success exponentially.

Is this starting to make sense? If not, comment below and let me know. 

homework for an artist's online art business

Map out the purpose (or message) of your next 12 newsletters. It doesn't need to be complicated — you can steal the "email life purposes" from above and double up your favorites, mix and match them, or create your own. This will give you a good starting point for your next 3 months to 1 year of newsletters (depending on how often you send them out).

call to action on creative newsletter

I have eleven calendars on my phone to keep my life sorted. It sounds a bit like insanity, right? Who does that?

Instead of pairing down, which isn’t really doable at the moment, I added yet another. But this one is different. It is a calendar of reminders of what I need to bring more of into my life. Every hour on the hour it reminds to be thankful or grounded, mindful or peaceful… whatever I think I will need that day.

6AM… DING! “Have gratitude today.”

7AM… DING! “Have gratitude today.”

and so on throughout my day.

You see, even if I tell myself that morning that I want to be more thankful, unless I remind myself to DO IT, it will probably not happen.

The alerts are my own personal calls to action, delivered hourly.

Calls to action in your emails are the same way. People know you want them to buy your art, or share your email, or like your Instagram page… but unless you remind them to DO IT, they probably won’t.

STEP 3: Tell them what you want them to do next. What action should your newsletter spark?

If your purpose is to:

  • Highlight your latest painting, tell them how to buy it.
  • Share a quote to brighten your readers’ day, send them to a related book you’ve read that you think will inspire them.
  • Talk about your process, send them to a video that explains it further.

I mentioned earlier, but it bears repeating. Some of your newsletters’ calls to action need to be self-serving to be in business. These CTAs might sound like: buy my art, follow me, or share me. If you’re afraid of asking for what you need, you MUST find a way to get over that. Talk yourself into doing it. Just once. Then once more. Remind yourself WHY you are doing it in the first place.

On the flip side, if the only CTAs you ever use are self-serving, people will eventually get tired of hearing from you. Like any good relationship, your business relationships should be give and take. If all you do is take, the energy between you will start to be very weighted to one side. Don’t forget to give back! If they know that you care about them, they’ll be more willing to give you their trust.

Now you know what you want them to do. But how do you tell your readers what to do in the most effective way possible? No problemo! Just follow this formula.

Your call to action formula:
  • 1
    What you want them to do
  • 2
    Exactly how to do it
  • 3
    A benefit they’ll receive by doing it or why you are asking them to do it.​​​​
PRO TIP: Don’t use phrases like “click here to read my blog” as your call to action.

No one actually cares about your blog or mine… they care about what they will get out of reading it.

Example #1: Click the link below to see more pictures of the garden that inspired this painting. You might want to use this color combo in your spring planters!

Example #2: If this newsletter gave you an idea of your next step, please forward it to three friends who are feeling a little lost right now. My dearest wish is to help others become clear on their life path using my art, and you can help me!

Example #3: If you think you might want to commission a drawing of your family just like this one someday, click here to read more about my process and how affordable it can be. Don’t wait until “someday” or “later” to create a family heirloom you can place above your fireplace now.

PRO TIP: Use specific details about your Ideal Art Buyer in your calls to action so they know you’re talking to them, like the examples above.
homework for an artist's online art business

Write your newsletter's CTA using the formula above this week and measure how many more clicks you get compared to your last few newsletters.​ If you haven't started an email list yet, use this CTA formula in your social media instead.

If you liked this article, sign up below to get more just like it in your inbox every week!

Do the work & create your luck,

Does this post speak your language? Please share it with other artists!

About the Author

Jessica Craddock is a consultant for artist entrepreneurs who are building their following online but haven’t figured out how to sell regularly. They’re deciding the world doesn’t understand or appreciate their art enough to buy it and self doubt is creeping in. She teaches them to present their art in ways that are “authentically them” so they can sell more through their website & spend their days creating beautiful things.

>